The chalice has cracked.
Not shattered, not discarded—but cracked. A visible fracture now runs through the cup we once shared across continents and cultures, in the name of Christ and the rhythm of common prayer. The Global Anglican Communion has declared itself apart from Canterbury, and the old bonds of affection have frayed into formal division.
I do not write this with triumph or bitterness. I write it with the ache of liturgical memory. I remember singing “I bind unto myself today” in a windswept chapel, knowing that others were singing it in Nairobi, Sydney, and Rio. I remember the quiet dignity of bishops washing feet, of lay readers proclaiming resurrection in borrowed robes, of choirs harmonizing across theological divides. I remember the Communion—not just as structure, but as sacrament.
And now, the chalice has cracked.
Some say it was inevitable. That truth demanded separation. That fidelity required a new wineskin. Others say it was betrayal. That love was abandoned. That unity was sacrificed on the altar of certainty.
But I say this: cracks are not the end of the story.
In the Rule of St Benedict, we are taught to receive the guest as Christ—even when the guest arrives with wounds, with disagreement, with a different liturgical accent. We are taught to prefer nothing to Christ, and to seek peace in the midst of conflict. We are taught that stability is not stagnation, but rootedness in grace.
So what do we do when the chalice cracks?
We keep pouring.
We pour blessing into the fracture. We pour lament into the silence. We pour hope into the ache. We pour prayer into the space between provinces, between primates, between pews.
And we remember: the first chalice cracked on the night He was betrayed. And still He said, “This is my blood, poured out for you.”
May we be faithful in the pouring.
O Christ, our wounded healer,
you prayed that we might all be one—
and tonight, we are not.
The chalice has cracked,
the cords of affection frayed,
and the family we loved has named its parting.
We bring you our sorrow, not our certainty.
We bring you our longing, not our labels.
We bring you the ache of broken fellowship,
and the hope that still flickers beneath the ash.
Bless those who walk away in grief,
and those who remain in silence.
Bless the bishops and the barefoot,
the prophets and the peacemakers,
the ones who feel betrayed,
and the ones who feel released.
Keep us from triumph and from despair.
Let no bitterness take root.
Let no truth be weaponized.
Let no love be lost.
And when the night deepens,
when the liturgy ends and the lights are dimmed,
may we remember:
you are still here,
still praying,
still pouring out your life
for a Church that breaks your heart
and bears your name.
Amen.



Leave a comment